
I could say that the picture means that taxes are going to kill us but, to be true, I only wanted to get your attention :-p.
(Btw, I took the pic some days ago while exploring the sim that hosts our park and shop, and discovered that the owner’s dance club also had a sex-gen bike and that one of the parcels had a public haunted cemetary. Sometimes it is funny to meet your neiborhoods :-)
I promise to be brief about VAT :-p
First, an apologice; in my previous post I thought LL was going to charge VAT in L$ purchase, causing double taxing, but I was mistaken. I still wonder if we are paing United States AND European Union taxes, and if it is a way to remove at least one, but it isn’t my turf, so let’s forget about it.
Second, while I usually enjoy Gwyn’s light hearted, possitive post style (check this one, are we really going to get a more stable system? I’ll belive when it I see it but, meanwhile, Havok 4! woot!), she was so wrong about taxation. I will simply thieve part of a comment at her page:
“Good luck with the tax authorities. They will love hearing your explanation of why you need SL as a business expense.”
Yes, VAT is part of the UE legal system, and we simply have to pay for it; but don’t try to sell us there will be a benefit, but helping the state… as Prokofy says: “I’ve been amazed that Europeans have been screeching as much as they have about being taxed for Second Life, given that their socialism has to have somebody pay for it.”
Yes, thinking about living in a place without free medical coverage gives me the shivers, but it doesn’t mean that it doesn’t hurt to have to pay taxes for it :-p. The more we get, the less we pay is a human desire, not an european one *winks*.
Even if I hate to pay attention to somebody like Prokofy (another flame example from her post at the end of the comment), I agree about that LL could had made things better, looking for a half way solution, like a partial discount to euro users… and yes, I am not saying they should do that; it is their money. But it whould had been good public relations.
And talking about public relations, Anony Mouse did write about VAT :-) I also think that the way they communicated it to us was flawed. In a land market in recesion, they should had given european sim owners time to try to sell their now too expensive lands. Remember that we are talking about more than a thousand real dollars “buying” payment that will be lost if they simply stop paying land fees.
In a lesser way, that is the same what happens with premium accounts. Do you know you are required an extra payment of 10$ to downgrade an account? I discovered that months ago, when I was going to upgrade mine, and decide against it. Why do you have to pay an extra month only to stop paying? Sounds like bad praxis to me.
And yes, in the case of VAT LL is simply doing what international law asks from them, but I still wonder:
- Do WOW users pay VAT on their montly fees, too? (Maybe they do, I don’t have the slightless idea :-p).
- Are we paying for UE VAT and United States taxes at the same time? If so, is that right or are we entitled a discount?
- Was LL required to pay, or they did simply rush to it, in one of the usual, self-covering, end-user unconcerned tactics we all are familiar with now?
Maybe LL needed to do it, and yes, all us are law abiding people *smiles*; but that doesn’t mean that it isn’t a hard hit for some people, and that it could had been approached in a better way. And yes, I know it is always easy to judge and say “they should had done this” after it happens, but still, it itches.
I readed long ago that one of the causes of death on MMORPG is to listen too much to their fans. Developers get swarmed with lot of petitions and even personal insults, and it ends in an ugly enviroment. So maybe ignoring the users and their needs, and doing what you think is right is the way to go.
But that doesn’t mean I like it.
In this digital world, maybe we still need frontiers. Maybe we still need to abide, or try to abide, local laws; but I like to think I am a citizen of Shakespeare’s unknown country, if no physically, in spirit. A country where things like imagination, effort and good will can overcome the pettiness that taints this one.Then I read this, or things like this, and I know that world is still far away for some ones :-p
“And the minute anybody steps on their tail like this, how quickly that nasty anti-Americanism of theirs comes to the surface, we’re told we’re SUV-driving religious fundamentalist racist freaks, and the Euros want to be left alone, in, oh, Amsterdam, to gamble, smoke pot, and get laid without prudish Americans on their case.”